Good writers are often fooled by the lure of plain English. Most academics in the humanities are not duped so easily, though. They understand the power of jargon, obscurity and incoherence. Those aspiring to follow in their footsteps would do well to consider the following tips and tricks.
Titles. Once upon a time, scholars thought titles should be succinct and descriptive. Now we know better. Instead, introduce your work with an unintelligible phrase such as 鈥淚nterrupted Modernity鈥, 鈥淪overeign Emergencies鈥, 鈥淥verthrowing Geography鈥 or 鈥淰iolent Accumulation鈥. 鈥淏odies that Speak鈥 and 鈥淓mpires without Imperialism鈥 also make for great titles, even if bodies cannot speak and empires cannot exist without imperialism. Everyone knows that confusion attracts attention. Obscure quotes also make for great titles, especially if they include grammatical errors or antiquated speech. 鈥淥h motherland I pledge to thee鈥, 鈥淲hat does not respect borders鈥 and 鈥淔ortress Europe in the field鈥 are good examples.
Invented words. Language is subject to your imagination, not the other way around. Change nouns into adjectives and adjectives into nouns. 鈥淗ypervisibility鈥, 鈥渋nteragentivity鈥, 鈥渋nteranimality鈥, 鈥減recoloniality鈥, 鈥渟paciality鈥 and 鈥渟ubalternity鈥 are all great words. Count the number of words you鈥檝e invented or new concepts you鈥檝e employed. Try doubling it.
Between, beyond and towards. Study the stuff 鈥between empire and identities鈥. Go beyond the Arab Spring, beyond desire. Work towards a post-Marxist historiography or theory of counter-modernity. Write about the genealogy of something or, better still, towards the genealogy of something. 鈥淭oward a genealogy of black female sexuality鈥 鈥 perfect!
探花视频
Shudder quotes. Language is poisonous, so it is essential to place shudder quotes around as many words as possible 鈥 the 鈥淲est鈥 and 鈥淕lobal South鈥, the 鈥淓uropean鈥 and 鈥渘on-European鈥 worlds, 鈥渢raditional鈥 healing practices and 鈥渕odern鈥 identities. There are no experts, only 鈥渆xperts鈥. Shudder quotes make it difficult for others to accuse you of philosophical naivety.
Verbs. Use verbs along with their passives in the same sentence as often as possible, as in 鈥淚 will address the spatial and temporal re-mapping of these two distinct traumatic memories as they shape and are shaped by one another.鈥 Scholars study the assumptions and ideologies that constitute and are constituted by aid. They try to grasp how traumatic events influence and are influenced by norms, identities and interests. This signals you have mastered the passive tense, and that the passive tense has been mastered by you.
探花视频
The re-prefix. You should repeat and re-repeat verbs as often as possible with a re-prefix. Aim to frame and re-frame, imagine and re-imagine, inscribe and re-inscribe. This signals and re-signals to your readers that you are in command of revisionism.
Agency. Style is important in the humanities, but so is content. Be sure that you find agency among the downtrodden. The people of the Global South did not adopt Western knowledge; they adapted it. They did not replicate European sciences but subverted their racist agendas. Muslim women have not learned feminism from the West; they were feminists long before feminism existed.
Obfuscation. Do not write about history or even historicity, only 鈥渉istoricality鈥. Colonialism is widely understood by the general public and should therefore be avoided. Instead study 鈥渃oloniality鈥, 鈥渟emicolonialism鈥 or 鈥淓urocolonials鈥. Physical violence is blas茅; real scholars write about 鈥渄iscursive violence鈥. Instead of modernity or even post-modernity, consider 鈥渢ransmodernities鈥 and 鈥渘onmodernities鈥. Forget memory; study 鈥減ost-memory鈥.
Complication. The general rule of thumb is to complicate simple ideas. 鈥淟iving together鈥, in the words of one scholar, 鈥渙scillates between the tone of practical serenity and tragic pathos, between philosophical wisdom and desperate anguish鈥. It is both 鈥渟imple evidence and the promise of the inaccessible鈥, while it opens the possibility of a 鈥渦nified self鈥 and 鈥渟ynchronous time鈥. If only this were more widely known, so much domestic friction could be avoided.
探花视频
Prepositions. Many verbs can take more than one preposition. Be sure to use as many of them as possible. The politics of protest have not escaped the intricacies of speaking about, for and instead of others. Memory-making occurs in and across multiple spaces. Modernity is emerging in and between Europe and the Arab world.
Trends. Nothing is stable or monolithic. Everything is fluid, fragmented, hybrid, multi-directional and unsusceptible to articulation. There are multiple modernities. Memory is polymorphous. Nothing is spatially fixed or geography-bound. The line between words and things is permeable. Binary oppositions are evil. Decentre everything. Blur boundaries. Jump into an abyss so deep and profound that no one has any idea what you are talking about.
Elegant incoherence. Use the word 鈥渁s鈥 to connect unrelated ideas without having to explain why they are related. Examples include 鈥渁rchitecture as relic鈥, 鈥渞esistance as negotiation鈥 and an analysis of the tension between 鈥渂ody as sign鈥 and 鈥渂ody as corpus鈥.
Sites. Everything is a site for discursive production. Performance apparently positions the post-colonial female body as a particularly charged site of cultural contestation in the process of constructing a hybrid subjectivity. The body is a site of rupture and signification. The law is a site of subaltern negotiations with the state.
探花视频
Interruption. Good scholars know to interrupt themselves mid-sentence for clarification. As one of them has explained, 鈥渁nalysis of diasporic memory 鈥 or, more accurately, remembrances 鈥 conjures other times and places鈥. This in turn 鈥渉elps us recognise the local population as imaginers and producers (and not, at best, merely consumers) of their own modernity 鈥 or perhaps better, nonmodernity, as the modernity that unfolded鈥. This signals to the reader your sense of profound anguish 鈥 or rather your mastery of interruption dashes 鈥 or, perhaps still better, your mastery of interruption parentheses.
Read next:聽How (not) to write: nine more tips for academics in the humanities
Search for academic jobs in the humanities
探花视频
Zachary J. Foster is a PhD candidate in Near Eastern studies at Princeton University and a product manager at Academia.edu. He would like to make clear that all the examples of unintelligible academese given above are real.
POSTSCRIPT:
Print headline: Muddying the waters
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to 罢贬贰鈥檚 university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?





