探花视频

Toe the line or get drafted: Russian students walk tightrope

Academics say mobilisation gives universities a powerful tool, with learners who get expelled facing being sent to the Ukrainian front

Published on
October 6, 2022
Last updated
October 10, 2022
Source: Getty

Fears of a broader draft could be used to聽suppress opposition to聽the war and further limit free speech on聽Russian campuses, giving universities a聽鈥減owerful tool鈥 to聽silence potential dissenters, academics worry.

To date, the Kremlin has said it is drafting only reservists to fight in Ukraine, with the presidential explicitly exempting students at public universities. But there is anxiety that more young recruits 鈥 including those with no聽combat history 鈥 could soon be聽tapped as聽Russian losses mount.

While university students were expected to remain exempt from Russia鈥檚 obligatory year-long military service, the war efforts have increased the risk for those students who step out of line, academics said.

鈥淚f you鈥檙e expelled, you go straight to the army鈥he universities now have an extremely powerful tool to pressure students for any social or political activities,鈥 said Anna Lyubimtseva, coordinator of the Freedom Degree project, which fields queries from Russian students facing dismissal.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Institutions could use the threat of conscription not only to stifle students鈥 criticism of the war, but also to maintain control over 鈥渂asically everything which will make an impact on universities鈥 image鈥, she said.

Anatoly Oleksiyenko, a聽professor聽at the Education University of Hong Kong, noted that universities had historically served as 鈥渟anctuaries鈥 for young men avoiding conscription. He agreed that institutions 鈥渉ave a聽lot of聽leverage over behaviour and attitudes of their male students鈥.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Igor Chirikov, a senior researcher at the Center for Studies in Higher Education at the University of California, Berkeley, said that with an ongoing war, 鈥渢he stakes are much higher鈥 for young men.

鈥淭he danger of being mobilised is still there for students, which is why a聽lot of them prefer to flee the country, despite assurances,鈥 he said.

Dr Chirikov noted that both inside and between institutions, the mobilisation has created rifts. Distance learners are not covered under the exemption for public university students, for example. More than 300,000 students at private universities were also initially not exempt under the 21聽September order.

While Russia鈥檚 Defence Ministry appeared to of the exemption on 1聽October, saying that private institutions would also benefit from an exemption, their early exclusion sent a聽message, said Dr Chirikov.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

鈥淭his creates threats to enrolment for a聽lot of private institutions. I聽don鈥檛 think it鈥檚 just a coincidence; it鈥檚 rather a trend to push on private education in Russia,鈥 he said.

But among academics, there was disagreement about whether mobilisation-related pressure would make much difference to learners.

鈥淚 am not sure the administration needs more tools to pressure the students 鈥 they are already deeply scared,鈥 said Greg Yudin, a聽professor at the Moscow School of Social and Economic Sciences. 鈥淚f they actually rebel, they will hardly mind this danger.鈥

Further down the line, the war could significantly shape Russia鈥檚 higher education landscape, some observers have speculated.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Ms Lyubimtseva predicted that, should the war continue into next autumn, it would cause men鈥檚 university enrolment to increase, driving more competition for places.

She said the situation would 鈥渙pen the door for corruption鈥, with young men likely bribing their way聽in. But even without bribes, some administrators might feel compelled to give young men a聽spot at their institution.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

鈥淸They] may feel this sympathy with boys that if they don鈥檛 give them a place, they may get sent to war,鈥 she said.

pola.lem@timeshighereducation.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT