Not everyone was rolling out the welcome mat when Peter Mathieson, previously dean of the Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry at the University of Bristol, was nominated to be vice-chancellor of the University of Hong Kong.
Chan Yuen-ying, director of HKU鈥檚 Journalism and Media Studies Centre, wrote on her blog in 2013 that 鈥渋f a medical professor from the British city of Bristol, with a population of 430,000, is to parachute into Hong Kong to鈥afeguard our freedom, that鈥檚 a big joke鈥.
Despite the apparently Bristol-phobic Professor Chan, Professor Mathieson got the job and started in April 2014. Within six months, Occupy Central had begun, with thousands of people taking to the streets to protest China鈥檚 decision to screen candidates in the 2017 election for the territory鈥檚 leadership. HKU, the territory鈥檚 oldest higher education institution, was on a political knife-edge, as its staff and students were among the leaders of the movement.
Speaking to 探花视频, Professor Mathieson said that 鈥渕y appointment was controversial. There were some voices speaking out against the appointment of an outsider 鈥 and somebody from [what they called] a 鈥榯wo-bit鈥 university in the West Country rather than from Oxford or Cambridge or Harvard.鈥
探花视频
He continued: 鈥淲hat entertains me more than anything else is that now, and especially last year during the democracy protests and during the political maelstrom that characterises Hong Kong almost every day of the week, is people鈥ay to me: 鈥業t must be such an advantage to be an outsider, you鈥檝e got no baggage鈥. I feel like saying: 鈥楬ang on a minute, wasn鈥檛 it me saying that before?鈥 鈥
Occupy Central began in September 2014. Benny Tai Yui-ting, an associate professor of law at HKU, is regarded as one of the co-founders of the movement.
探花视频
Professor Mathieson described the time of the protests as 鈥渇rightening in that I felt what I鈥檝e described as a quasi-parental responsibility for 27,000 students鈥.
He 鈥渨anted to encourage freedom of speech and freedom of expression so I wanted to make sure the students were free to express themselves 鈥 and the staff. But I was also concerned about their safety. There were times during last summer when there were real concerns that it could end in bloodshed. I felt a responsibility to try and do what I could do to try and avoid that.鈥

Professor Mathieson did, at one point, go to address protesters on the streets. A shows him urging a group 鈥 listening in polite silence 鈥 to 鈥減ut safety first鈥 and 鈥渘ot provoke conflict鈥. He said it would give them the chance to 鈥渃ontinue what has so far been a protest that has brought a lot of credit on the protesters鈥.
Dr Tai is the subject of an HKU audit committee inquiry into allegations that he mishandled donations in 2013 鈥 with critics seeing the case as being driven by political interference in the university in the wake of Occupy Central.
探花视频
Has Professor Mathieson felt pressure from government authorities in Hong Kong or China over the protests? Has there been any pressure over the Dr Tai case in particular?
鈥淭here鈥檚 pressure from all directions, from all sides of any argument,鈥 Professor Mathieson said. 鈥淭here鈥檚 pressure from staff, students, alumni, media, politicians, whoever else you might like to mention鈥here鈥檚 a range of opinion about all the issues, including the protests, including Benny Tai... I guess my job is to deal with that pressure and make sure that I make decisions that are in the best interests of the university.鈥
Professor Mathieson also referred to a slight dip in HKU鈥檚 performance in some university rankings.
鈥淭he elephant in the room, I suppose, is the concern about institutional autonomy and political freedoms and whether there are risks to HKU, and indeed other universities in Hong Kong, from the perception that we are in a politically complex and difficult environment,鈥 he said. 鈥淚 hope that鈥檚 not the case but we鈥檝e obviously got to work to combat that perception.鈥
探花视频
The 鈥渙ne country, two systems鈥 pact between China and Hong Kong granting the latter a degree of autonomy runs until 2047. Some expect that the mainland influence will grow 鈥 does that present a problem for universities in Hong Kong as guardians of academic freedom? How does Professor Mathieson see that developing in the coming years?
鈥淥r even days,鈥 he joked. 鈥淵ou鈥檙e right, we regard academic freedom and freedom of speech as absolutely core values. And I think part of my job is to articulate those. We can鈥檛 just take them for granted. We have to explain what we mean and why we think they are important.鈥
探花视频
POSTSCRIPT:
Article originally published as: 鈥業 felt quasi-parental duty to every student鈥 (25 June 2015)
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to 罢贬贰鈥檚 university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?




