探花视频

Chinese scholars need US backing on human rights

China鈥檚 pressure on its academics to toe an ideological line will increase if Trump focuses only on business, says Tao Zhang

Published on
January 12, 2017
Last updated
February 16, 2017
Chinese man in shop with cages
Source: iStock

Donald Trump鈥檚 recent tweets and statements about alleged Chinese protectionism and military build-up have undoubtedly riled the Beijing hierarchy. But some in China are cheered by the prospect of Sino-American relations being driven by pure deal-making, unperturbed by US nagging about democracy and human rights.

In a , venture capitalist and political scientist Eric Li argued that 鈥渨ithout the shackles of ideology, even the most competitive rivals can make deals鈥.

But if this change in the US approach materialises, its timing would be very bad. Chinese president Xi Jinping鈥檚 regime is ramping up ideological control, especially in higher education. Only last month, he in which he pointed out that 鈥淐hina鈥檚 higher education institutions are under the leadership of鈥 the Communist Party of China (CPC), and that as they shoulder 鈥渢he major responsibility of cultivating successors for the socialist cause鈥, they 鈥渕ust adhere to the correct political orientation鈥.

Such statements are not unusual. In May 2013, six months into Xi鈥檚 reign, the CPC allegedly issued a directive named the 鈥渟even don鈥檛 mentions鈥 to institutes of higher education. Leaked on social media, it outlined the topics that academics could not raise with students: universal values, press freedom, civil society, civic rights, historical mistakes by the CPC, elite cronyism and independent judiciary.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Subsequently, several high-profile academics were sacked. One was , professor of law at the East China University of Political Science and Law in Shanghai, who, in 2011, wrote an open letter to the education minister calling for an end to compulsory political and ideological education in schools and universities. Xia Yeliang, professor of economics at Peking University and a consistent critic of the Chinese government, also .

More mildly liberal intellectuals also suffered. , professor of law at the Northwest University of Politics and Law in Xi鈥檃n, was reportedly pressured into resigning because he encouraged critical discussion among students and invited guests to speak on sensitive issues. And, according to local reports, even a lowly Hangzhou college lecturer was removed from his teaching post and placed in charge of sports equipment after being accused of 鈥渟abotaging the stability and harmony of the college and of society鈥 by organising a discussion group on improving citizenship education.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

In January 2015, the CPC launched a further campaign of ideological control. The 鈥渟even don鈥檛 mentions鈥 became more directly referred to as 鈥淲estern values鈥. , education minister Yuan Guiren said: 鈥淣ever let textbooks promoting Western values appear in our classrooms.鈥

More academics were targeted. One leading critic of Chinese media censorship has told me that he was frequently 鈥渃alled back鈥 from his fieldwork 鈥 often in areas of social unrest 鈥 by his university department鈥檚 party secretary. His lectures were monitored by 鈥渦nknown strangers鈥, who appeared without warning. He was prevented from travelling to the UK for a research visit because of his support for Hong Kong鈥檚 pro-democracy Umbrella Movement in 2014. And, in 2015, he was dismissed for alleged 鈥減oor delivery鈥 of one module.

It was not always like this. China made huge progress in modernising education in the pre-Communist Republican period. For instance, in his time as chancellor of Peking University in the early 20th century, Cai Yuanpei became a champion of 鈥渇ree thinking鈥, encouraging diversity and tolerance among academics. He appointed radical Chinese intellectuals educated abroad to introduce and develop new cultural trends, and invited leading thinkers such as John Dewey and Bertrand Russell to deliver lectures that often contained explicit criticism of Chinese society and politics.

As China expert David Shambaugh says in his 2016 book, China鈥檚 Future, the central problem with modern China鈥檚 education system is the 鈥渆xtreme degree鈥 to which the political system 鈥渟tifles the entire intellectual sphere鈥. It is an enormous pity that a Trump White House seems so unlikely to put much pressure on the CPC to remedy that situation and allow Chinese academia to flourish.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Tao Zhang is a senior lecturer in the College of Arts and Science at Nottingham Trent University.

POSTSCRIPT:

Print headline:聽Party schools

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related universities

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT