探花视频

Books interview: Onora O'Neill

The author of Justice Across Boundaries: Whose Obligations? on Swallows and Amazons, W.B. Yeats and reading Henry Kissinger and Immanuel Kant

Published on
May 26, 2016
Last updated
May 31, 2016
Onora O'Neill, Baroness O'Neill of Bengarve

What books were your childhood favourites?
Once I moved on from picture books, I began to devour old-fashioned adventure stories wholly uncritically: from Swallows and Amazons to Treasure Island to Masterman Ready and The Three Musketeers. I read them at a gallop in order to find out what happened next, and would probably be very surprised to discover what I had missed if I reread them now.

You begin your new book Justice Across Boundaries: Whose Obligations? by considering Robert Frost鈥檚 鈥榮imple and deep鈥 Mending Wall. Have you a favourite poet?
Recently I鈥檝e gone back to W. B. Yeats. The 100th anniversary of the Easter Rising provoked fears 鈥 widely shared 鈥 that commemoration might turn to provocative celebration and damage the still fragile political settlement in Ireland. This sharpened my appreciation of those who refused a century ago to celebrate either war or rebellion. Yeats was pre-eminent among them. In An Irish Airman foresees his Death, he wrote 鈥淣or law, nor duty bade me fight/Nor public men, nor cheering crowds/A lonely impulse of delight/Drove to this tumult in the clouds/I balanced all, brought all to mind/The years to come seemed waste of breath鈥︹. And in Easter 1916 he captures both the grandeur and the costs of the rising: 鈥淎ll changed, changed utterly:/A terrible beauty is born鈥. In a world in which those who kill others for political ends are all too often misdescribed as 鈥渕artyrs鈥, Yeats鈥 austere clarity matters.

Justice Across Boundaries鈥 final chapter discusses bioethics, an area of longstanding interest to you. Whose work would you recommend to the lay reader interested in learning more about the subject?
Nearly all writing in bioethics is about medical treatment that individuals may or should receive, including innovative treatments such as those that deploy new reproductive and genetic technologies and various forms of 鈥渉uman enhancement鈥. I鈥檓 more interested in the ethics of public health, which does not aim solely at the treatment of individuals. I have enjoyed Norman Fowler鈥檚 short and compelling work AIDS: Don鈥檛 Die of Prejudice, which compares what happened in jurisdictions that took a public health approach with what happened in those that took a moralistic approach to the HIV/Aids crisis: the latter have suffered unnecessary and catastrophic rates of transmission. I also liked the reflective approach of Observing Bioethics by Ren茅e C. Fox and Judith P. Swazey.

You became a life peer in 1999, and thus a politician as well as a political philosopher. Whose writing on politics did you find most useful in this new chapter in your public life?
In reading on politics and economics I look for writers 鈥 there aren鈥檛 enough of them 鈥 who combine strong commitment to ideals and principles with tough-minded realism about what it takes to live by those principles. Two books that have impressed me recently are Henry Kissinger鈥檚 World Order: Reflections on the Character of Nations and the Course of History and Colin Mayer鈥檚 Firm Commitment: Why The Corporation is Failing Us and How To Restore Trust in It.聽Kissinger is deeply thoughtful about what it really takes to secure even a quite imperfect peace, and Mayer diagnoses the real economic costs of institutions whose only aim is the simple-minded pursuit of the bottom line. 聽

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Which recent works of fiction have you, as a philosopher, found most fulfilling and challenging?
At present all too many books that are not聽classified as fiction are filled with fictions 鈥 very often with standardised and irritating fictions. I find myself weary of writing that is predicated on fictitious views of individual autonomy; fictitious views about well-ordered preferences; fictitious views of the possibility of achieving perfection in policy and politics; and many other fictions. Novels can be a way of avoiding irritating fictions, and I enjoy those of Colm T贸ib铆n, Julian Barnes and Sebastian Barry, and Hans Fallada鈥檚 Alone in Berlin.

What was the last book you gave as a gift, and to whom?
Recent presents include Mary Beard鈥檚 SPQR: A History of Ancient Rome for a classicist son, and Gerald Durrell鈥檚 My Family and Other Animals for a 10-year-old granddaughter who loves drawing animals.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

What books are you presently reading, or are on your desk waiting to be read?
As usual I have a number of partly read philosophy books waiting for the fuller attention they need. At present, they include Rudolf A. Makkreel鈥檚 Orientation and Judgment in Hermeneutics, Reidar Maliks鈥 Kant鈥檚 Politics in Context and Kenneth R. Westphal鈥檚 How Hume and Kant Reconstruct Natural Law. During the past 15 years, I have found Immanuel Kant鈥檚 late political writings deeply absorbing and it is exciting to find this enthusiasm increasingly widely shared.

Baroness O鈥橬eill of Bengarve, a cross-bench peer in the House of Lords, is former principal of Newnham College and emeritus honorary professor of philosophy, University of Cambridge, and author of (Cambridge University Press).

POSTSCRIPT:

Print headline: Shelf Life

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT