探花视频

Labour鈥檚 policy to scrap fees: memorable and popular (unless you鈥檙e the Daily Mail)

John Morgan looks at how Jeremy Corbyn's pledge has gone down with the public and the press

Published on
June 2, 2017
Last updated
June 2, 2017
Jeremy Corbyn
Source: Getty

A couple of things are clear about Jeremy Corbyn and Labour鈥檚 pledge to abolish tuition fees and bring back maintenance grants in England: it has stuck with the public as a clear, memorable policy and it is popular.

Putting its strengths or weaknesses as policy aside for the moment, the 拢11.2 billion pledge does seem to have been effective politics thus far. Polling by YouGov has found that scrapping fees scored top when it asked voters to remember , in their own words without prompting. The policy was cited by 32 per cent.

By contrast, the Conservatives most recognised policy was 鈥渃are reforms or dementia tax鈥, cited by 36 per cent.

Anthony Wells of YouGov said scrapping fees was among Labour policies 鈥渨hich our polling has found the public support, and which are relatively clear and easy to understand鈥. Wells was referring to polling after the publication of the leaked version of Labour鈥檚 manifesto, for which fieldwork took place on 11-12 May.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

YouGov asked respondents for their views on six Labour manifesto policies. Overall, on scrapping tuition fees and bringing back grants, 49 per cent said it was a good idea, 36 per cent said it was the wrong priority and 15 per cent didn鈥檛 know.


Find our where students could most impact the general election result


Support was high among those planning to vote Labour (76 per cent thought it a good idea). There was also strong support among 18-24 year olds, the younger voters whom Corbyn is targeting (58 per cent thought it a good idea). Middle-class ABC1s liked it (53 per cent good idea) but so did working-class C2DEs on balance (45 per cent good idea, 32 per cent wrong priority).

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

That put scrapping fees as out of the six Labour manifesto pledges YouGov tested, with capping rent rises in line with inflation and increasing income tax for people earning over 拢80,000 scoring more highly. Not the most popular, but combining decent popularity with being memorable.

I thought the manifesto commitment on fees was sloppily written (it isn鈥檛 true to say that 鈥渓ast year saw the steepest fall in university applications for 30 years鈥) and that Corbyn had made much better attempts to explain the rationale behind the policy in his University and College Union speech and 探花视频 interview. But the detail of the policy in the manifesto wording clearly isn't the most important thing when it comes to impact with voters.

Perhaps because Labour's fees policy was popular, the Daily Mail has been gunning particularly hard for it. The newspaper ran a 23 May story suggesting that 鈥渦niversities would be damaged鈥 by the policy, according to vice-chancellors (based on fairly measured comments from Universities UK鈥檚 Nicola Dandridge).聽That was accompanied by a leader column on Labour鈥檚 鈥渇lagrant attempt to bribe students鈥.

There was more from the Mail on 30 May, when it said that Corbyn 鈥渉as pledged to reduce or even write off 拢30 billion of student debt, without saying how it would be paid for鈥.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

That was based on the Labour leader鈥檚 NME , in which he talked about those who had already taken out loans under the 拢9,000 fees system, saying the party was 鈥渓ooking at ways that we could reduce that, ameliorate that, lengthen the period of paying it off, or some other means of reducing that debt burden鈥.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies has indeed put the value of the outstanding stock of student loans (some of which are maintenance rather than fee loans) . Corbyn was careful not to commit to simply writing off outstanding loans, so he seems to have been properly briefed about the issues and costs here.

Corbyn gave a mention to the fees policy in the leaders鈥 (and stand-in) televised debate in Cambridge this week. He referred to the 拢11.2 billion cost (he just dropped it in casually to show he can remember how much his policies cost) and said it would be 鈥渕oney well spent鈥 as an investment for the future.

Whether the onslaught against the policy from the Mail (and also the Sun) makes any difference to the policy鈥檚 popularity would be intriguing to see. But on the polling to date, the combination of being both memorable and popular has made it one of the most effective policies of the Labour聽campaign.

探花视频

ADVERTISEMENT

Unless Labour loses heavily and Corbyn is ejected from power, the party looks likely to stick with its thus far popular policy of publicly-funded higher education, which might be a significant shift in the debate about how England funds its universities.

john.morgan@timeshighereducation.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT